Willow Street Homes under $500,000

Willow Street Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Willow Street, Pennsylvania—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lancaster County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly community, Willow Street offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With its lush greenery, inviting parks, and vibrant local culture, this quaint village provides an idyllic setting for families, retirees, and young professionals alike.

One of the standout features of Willow Street is its affordability, particularly when it comes to housing. With an array of charming homes available for under $500,000, this area is an attractive option for those seeking a place to call home without breaking the bank. From cozy single-family residences to spacious townhouses, you'll find a variety of styles that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. Many of these homes boast beautiful yards, ample living space, and proximity to local amenities, making them perfect for both relaxation and entertainment.

The community is enriched by its proximity to Lancaster City, where you can explore a vibrant arts scene, indulge in farm-to-table dining, and enjoy unique shopping experiences. Willow Street is also conveniently located near major highways, providing easy access to nearby attractions and cities.

Whether you're looking to start a new chapter in your life or invest in a promising real estate opportunity, Willow Street is a wonderful place to set down roots. Explore the charming homes under $500,000 that await you in this delightful part of Pennsylvania, and discover the welcoming community that makes Willow Street truly special.

Newest Willow Street Homes under $500,000

403 Wynwood Dr, Willow Street
$479,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
This classy home in the LS School District sits on a quiet, sought-after street close to everything. The sellers have poured care into many costly updates, and the home is in amazing condition and absolutely ready to move into! Updated flooring runs throughout, and fresh paint brightens many rooms. The refreshed kitchen offers brand new granite countertops and backsplash, updated lighting, and a newer refrigerator that stays with the home. Natural light pours into the main living area, where a stone wood-burning fireplace sets the scene for cozy evenings. Both full baths have been updated, including a beautifully modernized primary suite and bath with a new tub. This home has the option for first floor living with its spacious bedroom and bath on the main level. Downstairs, the fully finished basement offers a storage room, and plenty of space for movie nights or game day gatherings. Out back, the private rear deck looks over a spacious yard framed by mature landscaping, complete with two sheds and a swing set. It’s a peaceful spot for morning coffee or summer cookouts. You’ll also love the large first-floor laundry room and an attached garage currently set up as a home gym. Behind the scenes, the big-ticket items are taken care of: a replaced furnace and water heater, a new sewer line from the house to the public connection, a new deck, and a radon mitigation system.

403 Wynwood Dr, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of Kingsway Realty - Lancaster. Contact:

1578 Beaver Valley Pike, Willow Street
$500,000
REAL ESTATE AUCTION / November 9, 2026 @ 4 pm List price of $500,000.00 is a suggested opening bid only and is not indicative of the final sale price. TERMS: $50,000.00 down at Auction - Settlement on or before December 21, 2026. – Excellent 4-Unit Investment Opportunity in Strasburg Township! Don't miss this outstanding opportunity to purchase a well-maintained, income-producing 4-unit residential investment property situated on 1 acre in the desirable Lampeter-Strasburg School District. This property consists of a 4-unit apartment building featuring three 2-bedroom, single-story apartments, along with a separate 3-bedroom, single-story apartment with an attached 25' x 13' garage. All four units are currently occupied, generating a total gross rental income of $4,925 per month or $59,100 annually! Unit 1 features an eat-in kitchen/dining area with painted cabinetry and appliances, mudroom with laundry, 2 bedrooms, full bath with tub/shower, small basement, electric baseboard heat, and 100-amp service. Currently rented for $1,300/month. Unit 2 offers a similar 2-bedroom layout with eat-in kitchen, laundry area, and full bath, along with new windows, kitchen cabinets, and countertops installed in 2023. Currently rented for $1,250/month. Unit 3 features an eat-in kitchen/dining area with attractive stone accent walls, mudroom with laundry, 2 bedrooms, full bath with walk-in shower, and small basement. Currently rented for $1,025/month. The three-unit apartment building received a new metal roof in 2026! Unit 4 is a separate 3-bedroom apartment featuring an eat-in kitchen/dining area, mudroom with laundry, full bathroom with tub/shower, additional bathroom with shower stall, small basement, and attached garage. New windows and minor interior updates were completed in 2020. Currently rented for $1,350/month. All four apartments feature electric baseboard heat, LP water heaters, and 100-amp electrical service. The property is situated on a spacious 1-acre lot with lawn areas, gravel driveway and ample off-street parking. Enjoy a peaceful country setting while remaining conveniently located near Routes 272 and 372, with easy access to Quarryville, Willow Street, and surrounding Lancaster County communities. A great cash-flowing investment property with established rental income and numerous recent improvements! Whether you're looking to expand your investment portfolio or purchase your first multi-unit rental property, this is an excellent year-end real estate auction opportunity!

1578 Beaver Valley Pike, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of Stoltzfus Realty. Contact:

223 Norbury Cir, Willow Street
$339,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to 223 Norbury Circle, where you get the space you want without giving up your weekends. This home is built for easy living, with spacious floor plans that give everyone room to breathe and plenty of flexibility for how you actually live day to day. The dining room opens right out onto a large deck, so summer dinners, morning coffee, and evenings with friends all have a natural spot to happen. The eat-in kitchen is set up for real life, with a bar for quick breakfasts or a spot for friends to pull up a stool and watch the game, plus a separate eating area for family meals. And let’s talk about that garage. It’s oversized with a workshop, which is a rare find. Whether you’re a woodworker, a tinkerer, or just someone who needs real room for tools and toys, you’ll have the space to do it right. Best of all, mowing and snow removal are taken care of. No dragging out the mower on a Saturday, no shoveling the driveway before work in January. You get to enjoy your home instead of maintaining it. The location is a big plus, too. You’re in the Penn Manor School District. Downtown Lancaster is just minutes up the road for dining, shopping, and Central Market, and Kendig Square makes everyday errands a breeze. Lancaster County Central Park and the historic Hans Herr House are close by, and if you head south you’re into some of the prettiest country in the county, with Pinnacle Overlook and the river trails. Strasburg Rail Road and Dutch Wonderland are an easy drive for family days out. Spacious, low maintenance, and a garage you’ll actually love. This one checks a lot of boxes. Schedule your showing today!

223 Norbury Cir, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of Kingsway Realty - Ephrata. Contact:

110 Lynette Cir, Willow Street
$339,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Great Willow Street Location! With lots of TLC and a good handyman, this 2–3 bedroom Rancher offers the convenience of comfortable one-story living. The eat-in kitchen features a double sink and plenty of cabinet space, while the sizable family room opens to a rear deck—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The flexible floor plan offers the option of three bedrooms or two bedrooms plus an office/den. A main-level laundry room, full bathroom with tub/shower, and convenient half-bath powder room add to the home’s functionality. An oversized garage is accessible from inside the home and also features a walk-in door from the outside. The large full basement provides excellent additional space for storage, a workshop or hobby area, rec area, and more. With the proper improvements, there is also potential to finish most of the basement and significantly expand the home’s finished living space. Situated on a quiet street in a cul-de-sac, this home is just minutes from grocery stores, shopping, specialty markets, and restaurants. Enjoy the best of both worlds with convenient access to everyday amenities while being just a short drive from the beautiful countryside of rural Lancaster County—perfect for scenic Sunday drives and stops at local ice cream shops!

110 Lynette Cir, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Evolved. Contact:

703 Danforth Cir, Willow Street
$330,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
PRICE REDUCTION! Welcome Home at 703 Danforth Circle in Willow Street Pa 17584. This impeccable home built in 2020, offers modern comfort, spacious living areas, and an exceptional layout for everyday living and entertaining. The first floor features an inviting open-concept floor plan with an impressive 11-foot upgraded ceiling, creating a bright and spacious atmosphere throughout the large living room and dining area. The well-appointed kitchen offers 36-inch-high wall cabinets, a raised bar top with additional seating, a large pantry, and ample closet space. Upstairs, you’ll find three bedrooms, including a spacious Owner’s Suite with its own bathroom, along with full bathroom and the convenience of a second-floor laundry room. A powder room on the main level adds an extra touch of convenience for guests. Additional highlights include an oversized two-car garage and generously sized driveway, providing plenty of parking and storage. Step outside to the large roof terrace deck—an ideal space for outdoor dining, relaxing, and entertaining guests. The property is conveniently located within walking distance to Pequea Elementary School and close to Farmland, Orchards, the famous Pineview dairy, for shopping and fresh, locally grown farm produce, making it easy to enjoy the best of the surrounding Willow Street and Lancaster County area. Equipped with heat pump installed in 2020, you have no worry over hot summers or cold winters all in the same electric bill. Whether you're a first time buyer or downsizing, the open floor plan, upgraded finishes, abundant space, and fantastic outdoor living area, 703 Danforth Circle offers a wonderful opportunity to enjoy comfortable, modern living in Willow Street.

703 Danforth Cir, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 Home Advisors. Contact:

527 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street
$395,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Home is in the process of being remodeled. Permits were obtained. Professional photos are forthcoming. Exterior tours are permitted. Property is in the drywall stage. Buyer has the option to choose finishing touches. Be sure to inquire. Welcome to 527 Baumgardner Road. A single-family home with panoramic views of nature. This beauty sits on 0.56 acres. With a full renovation on every floor, your new home awaits your gentle touch. The first floor is separated by a middle stairway. Living room and dining room sit one each side. The galley kitchen sits in the rear along with an enlarged walk-in pantry, laundry area (washer and dryer included), half bathroom and access into the 2-car garage. The kitchen includes stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, natural sunlight and much more! Ascend to the second floor where four bedrooms and a hallway bathroom are positioned. The owner's suite is equipped with walk-in closets and an owner's bathroom. Flooring throughout the home includes: 3/4-inch hardwood floors, carpet and ceramic tiles. AV opportunities are located for your convenience in the living room and owners suit. An abundance of recessed lighting are present too. The basement is unfinished but prepared to host your storage. The rear of the property accommodates 2 additional off-street parking spaces. Take a few steps up into your private oasis. The developer created a private deck and entertainment space for your future events. The rear year extends into the trees. Be prepared to fall in love!

527 Baumgardner Rd, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of Fowler and Co. Contact:

4 Bauer Ave, Willow Street
$350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 1-bath home in Willow Street, located in the well-regarded Penn Manor School District. The layout is comfortable and practical, with a sunroom porch off the back that's a great spot to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind at the end of the day. Out back you'll find a large yard with plenty of room to garden, play, or simply spread out, plus a two-car garage for parking, storage, or a workshop.

4 Bauer Ave, Willow Street

Listing courtesy of Foraker Realty Co.. Contact:

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!