Cabbage Hill Homes under $400,000

Cabbage Hill Homes under $400,000

Welcome to Cabbage Hill, a charming and vibrant subdivision nestled in the heart of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Known for its rich history and tight-knit community, Cabbage Hill offers a unique blend of urban convenience and suburban tranquility. This delightful neighborhood is characterized by its picturesque streets, beautifully maintained homes, and a warm sense of community that makes it a perfect place to call home.

Cabbage Hill is a fantastic choice for homebuyers seeking affordability without compromising on quality. With a variety of homes available for under $400,000, this area provides an excellent opportunity for first-time buyers, families, and those looking to downsize. The homes in this subdivision showcase a mix of architectural styles, from charming historic residences to modern builds, ensuring there’s something to suit every taste and preference.

Living in Cabbage Hill means you’re just a stone’s throw away from the vibrant downtown Lancaster, where you can enjoy an array of shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions. Stroll through the local farmer's market, explore art galleries, or indulge in the culinary delights offered by renowned eateries. The community spirit is palpable, with numerous events and gatherings that foster connections among neighbors.

For those who appreciate outdoor activities, Cabbage Hill is conveniently located near parks and recreational facilities, providing ample opportunities for hiking, biking, and enjoying nature. With its ideal location, affordable housing options, and welcoming atmosphere, Cabbage Hill is truly a hidden gem in Lancaster, PA—waiting for you to discover your dream home!

Newest Cabbage Hill Homes under $400,000

474 Poplar St, Lancaster
$299,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to 474 Poplar St where you can have instant equity! Appraised at $318k July 2025. Featuring 2 Beds | 2.5 Baths | Fully Renovated in 2025 | Historic Charm Meets Modern Luxury. A rare opportunity to own a completely reimagined single-family home in the heart of Lancaster City’s vibrant SOWE/Cabbage Hill neighborhood. Originally built in 1890 and fully renovated in 2025, this historic townhome blends timeless character with sophisticated modern finishes—every inch thoughtfully restored. Step inside to an open-concept main level featuring luxury vinyl plank flooring, fresh paint, high-end crown molding, and pre-wired TV outlets for flexible living room arrangements. The centerpiece: a gourmet galley kitchen with quartz countertops and full backsplash, soft-close cabinetry, premium stainless-steel appliances, an undermount sink with high-end faucet and disposal button, and a dedicated coffee bar/appliance nook—a chef’s dream with functional elegance. Upstairs, you’ll find two spacious bedrooms including a primary suite with ensuite bath, plus a conveniently located 2nd-floor laundry area. All bathrooms are brand-new with ceramic tile, upscale fixtures, and modern design. The basement level offers even more flexibility with stone and brick accents, clean finishes, and space ideal for a home gym, wine cellar, or cozy lounge. Enjoy the outdoors in the large backyard with new sod and plenty of room for entertaining or relaxing. Key exterior upgrades include: Full roof replacement, new gutters, and downspouts All new windows, doors (front & rear), and fresh paint Brick repointing, masonry repairs, and updated steps/railings Yale smart keypad locks for front and back entries Major mechanical updates provide peace of mind: All-new 100-amp electrical panel & wiring Brand-new HVAC system (gas heat, electric AC) and full ductwork New hot water heater Recessed lighting with dimmer switches throughout. This is more than a renovation—it’s a rebirth of a historic home with modern comforts, low-maintenance systems, and timeless appeal, just minutes from Lancaster’s best dining, shopping, and downtown culture. Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of Lancaster history—fully updated for modern living. Home also has proper setup for Xfinity or Verizon Fios using Fiber Optic with speeds that are insanely fast! Nothing to do besides move in! Schedule your showing today! (Showings on weekends preferred, and after 6pm on weekdays.)

474 Poplar St, Lancaster

Listing courtesy of Zoom Realty, LLC. Contact:

445 St Joseph St, Lancaster
$230,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Classic Lancaster City character with flexibility for primary residence or investment property. The property is currently tenant-occupied on a month to month lease for $1,695/month. Tenants would like to stay, but understand a buyer may end their lease with 28 days notice. Located in the Cabbage Hill neighborhood, this home offers approximately 1,910 SF with four bedrooms, full bathroom and powder room. Both bathrooms remodeled in June 2022. Inside, tall windows and an open living and dining area create a bright, comfortable first floor. The updated kitchen features white cabinetry, recessed lighting, and an exposed brick accent wall that adds warmth and character. First-floor laundry is conveniently located between the kitchen and rear mudroom. The upper floors offer generously sized bedrooms, while the finished third floor provides flexible space for an additional bedroom, home office, studio, or recreation area. The unfinished basement provides additional storage. Outside, enjoy a fenced yard and side patio with space for outdoor dining or relaxing, along with a small storage shed. Additional highlights include a distinctive arched front entry, decorative cornice, and front section of property new shingle roof installed in 2022. The home has gas hot water radiator heat and electric baseboard heat. Gas hot water. Showings may begin Monday September 21st.

445 St Joseph St, Lancaster

Listing courtesy of PPM Real Estate, Inc.. Contact:

17 New Dorwart St, Lancaster
$399,900
Multi-unit turnkey opportunity in the always growing Cabbage Hill area of Lancaster City.  This location is perfect for an investor or someone looking to live in one unit while renting the other. Completely renovated 2 unit in 2023 from top to bottom. New roof, HVAC, Windows, Electrical (separated for both units), Plumbing, and all cosmetics. All appliances are included in the sale plus it has a washer and dryer to appeal to ideal tenants. Both leases are on a month to month lease but welcome to extend if buyers would like. Come check it out today for a growing area in Lancaster City. 

17 New Dorwart St, Lancaster

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Elite. Contact:

428 Lafayette St, Lancaster
$254,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome to 428 Lafayette St, a specious 4 bed 2 bath semi-detached home conveniently located in Lancaster city with easy access to downtown, shopping, dining, parks and major routes. Step inside to fresh paint, new flooring and several new windows throughout, creating a bright and refreshed interior ready for its next owner. The functional layout offers plenty of space and highlights a second floor laundry room adding convenience to every day living. Outside is a completely fenced yard perfect for relaxing, entertaining, pets or play. Six months of off street parking is being offered with an acceptable offer! With four bedrooms, two full baths, outdoor space, convenient laundry, and a central Lancaster location, this home offers a great combination of space, functionality, and value. Schedule your tour today!

428 Lafayette St, Lancaster

Listing courtesy of Realty One Group Alliance. Contact:

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!